Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Vitamin P, the excommunication of Hannah Arendt and The Sublime.

Pine

    We could read Arendt's book Eichmann in Jerusalem together, but I am not going to expect that from you. Instead I will point to the sublime of justice and say Justice is "The Right to have Rights," everything else is paperwork and myth.

    I use the word sublime to reiterate the certainty that rights are not god given. In a society of people, 'rights' are better thought of as evidence of governance in a society managed by rules understood to be common to all.

    Arendt's book Eichmann in Jerusalem records an account of her witness to the evidence presented, along with the arguments of the defendant and of the state of Israel in the 1961 trial of Adolf Eichmann. If we were to read this book together as disciples rather than critics we would I believe begin to get a sense of what Arendt herself understood by the word Justice. 

   Early on in her understanding is her grasp of "who you know." She mentions Vitamin P - the P is from a Hebrew word for protection - an Israeli expression that means using personal connections, influence, or favoritism to get ahead, rather than the merit trusting the rules. Many would argue "who you know" is not right.

  Arendt spoke about Eichmann's Defense Council, a German legal mind called Dr. Robert Servatius who had never joined the Nazi Party, didn't speak Hebrew but who as well as his native German, spoke English fluently, French and Russian. Robert Servatius during the war had been an Artillery Officer. 

   Three judges managed the proceeding. The lead prosecutor was a man called Gideon Hausner, his father had been a Zionist, was born in Poland, he'd immigrated to the Palestinian Mandate in 1927 when he was 12 years old. He was in the Hagnah, a paramilitary group and the least militant of Zionist paramilitary groups in the years leading up to Arab-Israeli war of 1948 which resulted in Israel becoming a nation recognized by the US President Truman. The Hagnah formed the core of the Israeli Defence Force. Gideon Hausner, between 1960 through 1963 he was Israel's Attorney General.

   As the trial began, there was panapoly of theater and hope as well as elements of hypocrisy evident to Arendt in the similarities between the 1935 Ordinances of  Nuremberg which prevented German people marrying Jews and the Israeli constitution of 1953 which declared the unions between men and women and the status of their children to be a matter for Religious Courts to determine.

    Arendt painted a picture of the court as an attempt to achieve the impossible, this wasn't banditry, this wasn't a bank robbery, the Trail of Eichmann was an attempt to reach a just solution to the human condition and in the course of the trial Arendt concluded she'd write a report on the banality of evil, a white collar crime. A conclusion that mightily pissed off those who believed in the perfectibility of our species, a belief that demanded a right and a wrong.

   Adolf Eichmann had trail before he was hanged.

     Our question is this: Did the social structure of the Passenger Pigeon rely on Vitamin P or did it rely on Common Law. The sublime for the Passenger Pigeon was other Passenger Pigeons. The sublime for us people is somewhere else, lost between our ears, busily reinventing itself.

Sunday, November 15, 2026

One to Another

Semi-domestic Mackerel Tabby

    Early in Thomas Hobbes' Leviathan, his search for the "Mother Forme and Power of the Commonwealth, Ecclesiasticall and Civill" is a 1651 understanding of a Latin word conscius which Hobbes translated as "knowing together." When a person is alone Hobbes recognized a "knowing in oneself" but Hobbes declared that conscius was much more than "knowing in oneself," conscius, when two or more people know one and the same fact they are "conscius of it one to another."

    That kind of one to another knowing was a Leviathan, which when left to it's natural state in us people would remain "raw in tooth and claw." But, Hobbes argued, the Leviathan did not have to be forever in nature. Hence the Social Contract, a consciousness of fact one to another, that tames a Leviathan, creates a new beast, gentler and kinder based upon laws of contract and justice - a sensible one to another of the same fact.

   Then came Locke, a man you either love or hate, a progenitor of an English Speaking understanding of Freedom, his Essay Concerning Human Understanding, his individual, produced "the perception of what passes in a man's mind." This more singular, isolated and skinny definition of consciousness was entered into Samuel Johnson's English Language Dictionary, where in 1755 it became official.

   "The Public Square" was Hannah Arendt's pursuit of one to another. She never finished her analysis of Justice, but she explored the role of one to another as the principle means by which a society was able to choose direction, which in those days, because the word direction was a little too Ouspensky goo-goo land Eastern mystic, was referred to in terms of destiny. More useful perhaps for Arendt's way of thinking was control over, or at least contribution to destiny.

Saturday, November 14, 2026

End Times for Mammon

Apple Red Delicious

    What is there in our being that allows us to match wits with the meanings in the symbols "death," "extinction," as well as "blessed release" the meanings in "departure," "expire," "end," it's a list of dissolving states that would include the communal notions in "eradicate" and "genocide."

   One thing the Passenger Pigeon might have mastered was a communal "all for one, one for all" that massively exceeds our "in god we trust." Probably an arrogance that left the Passenger Pigeon with an unsupported sense of invincibility, the sort of bog-shittery that leads some of my own species into the valleys which in exchange for a selfie decry something as simple as a vaccine and attempts to carve a golden calf out of an orange baboon.

   "Bad mood?"

   I mean good lord, a good salty Caerphilly from the sheep milk, before the milk cows got all special, but my mood's no worse than usual comrade. Had enough of the landlords, that's all. We need our own ram, renting it from some dick-wit in a tee-shirt surely sucks as our work is stolen and then reinvented as a super intelligence to which we are indentured. 

    Believe me, some sheep go rogue, they'll follow you through the braken, they won't head butt you, they'll bite at you and instead of bruised, they'll leave you wondering about rabies.

    "Really."

     Think pitchforks.

Friday, November 13, 2026

Where was the World until we made it

Osage

      Easy enough to divide the world into Physical and its opposite. A division between the real and an abstract theory. But separating these two jovial rivals as they tussle for dominance, ain't easy. Neither sits comfy on a shelf, and never will they purr at each other for longer than a second or two. 

    The Hindus have the Physical World. Then they have the Astral or Subtler World. And they have the Even Subtler World, it's a transcendental place, above all others, it's the World of Pure Consciousness, the world of idea, from which the Great Shinning Beings, or Gods, manifest the bounty of Physical World and the essential rattiness of the less Subtler, or Astral World.

    Long before these manifestation of the Gods were woven into the written word, they were transmitted in song, long endless stories, dance and tradition. The campfire at night, the flicker of ash, a distant hyena, a rustle in the bushes, the padding around of some kind of cat with big teeth. Must of been terrifying but plenty of chance for the High T individual to demonstrate actual usefulness around the home. 

    The question for now goes this way: Long before the word, or message, or before chapter one was ever shared, what and where was the world?

     Offensive though it might sound, Jung, in an attempt to explore his understandings of an archaic archetype of person-hood traveled to the slopes of East Africa's Mount Elgon and then on to the Indian Subcontinent to find minds unadulterated by modernity. He had no luck.

    Here, where I am, the search is for the source of physical and its opposite in pre-language mind. Here, and I'll endeavor not to reach for the holy water to preserve me from the evil indolence of Utility Theory, I think we can argue that in the hands of a tool making species language is yet another useful tool. 

    As a tool, language, for a post language mind, provided the means to share and interpret subtleties as well as complexities already present in the pre-language mind. There would have been shareable ideas such as "Funny thing about that bird, we only ever see it when there's a bee hive nearby." "What's that?" "Bee hive means honey-glazed warthog chops." "Which bird?" "The yellow one."

     More interesting is a creature such as the Passenger Pigeon. A social creature that gathered by the thousand in clouds of chatter. They were no match for the shotgun, no match for hungry cities, nor was flight a means of escape for them. Call it what you like but there is literature which suggests that loss of habitat, intense hunting and the collapse of a Passenger Pigeon Social Structure produced an ennui that drove them to extinction. 

    I'd argue that had the Passenger Pigeon developed a more complex means of communication, the invention of God would have saved it. Same with the Dodo.